image ofA/B testing in email marketing

A/B Testing in Email Marketing: Your Comprehensive Guide 2024

Posted: | Last updated:


With the rise of content creators and social media, it can be easy to look at email marketing as an obsolete strategy. But with billions of active email users globally and thousands of brands diving into email marketing, it is safe to say that this type of digital marketing strategy continually produces results to this day. However, the real challenge is creating email marketing campaigns that are effective and successful. Fortunately, A/B testing in email marketing is a method you could use to yield successful results. 

email users statistics
Statistics prove that billions of people still access their emails. Source: Oberlo

What is A/B testing in email marketing, and why is it crucial? 

Key Takeaways

A/B testing in email marketing is a crucial part of your efforts. Without it, you can hardly determine the emails that help you hit your marketing objectives and drive your desired results. Conducting this test requires time and serious effort, but with an email testing tool, you can optimize the process and save time. 

What is A/B Testing in Email Marketing?

opened laptop
A/B testing in email marketing MUST not be dismissed.

A/B testing in email marketing, otherwise known as “split testing,” is a strategic method that allows you to compare two different versions of an email to see which one performs better in terms of achieving your desired marketing goals, such as higher open rates, click-through rates, or conversions. The process involves splitting your email subscribers into two groups randomly, with one group receiving Version A of the email and the other receiving Version B.

The email versions typically differ in one aspect, such as the subject line, call-to-action button, or overall layout. By analyzing the performance metrics of each version, you can gather valuable insights into what resonates more effectively with your audience. This data-driven approach helps you make informed decisions about optimizing future email campaigns for better engagement and results.

Performing A B testing in email marketing can be done easily through email marketing tools, as you can use these tools to create two different emails and automatically send the emails to two distinct subsets of your email list. After determining the winning email, the tool will send that version to the rest of your email list. 

What is The Purpose of A/B Testing in Email Marketing?

The purpose of A/B testing in email marketing is to enhance the effectiveness of your email campaigns by leveraging data-driven insights. By comparing two different versions of an email, you can determine which elements resonate better with your audience and drive higher engagement.

This could include testing variations in subject lines, email copy, call-to-action buttons, images, or overall design. The ultimate goal is to optimize your emails for higher open rates, click-through rates, conversions, or any other metric you aim to improve.

A/B testing in email marketing is more than just a routine of your email marketing campaigns. It empowers you to make informed decisions based on performance data rather than relying solely on assumptions or best guesses.

This systematic and iterative process of testing and refining helps you tailor your email marketing strategies better to meet the needs and preferences of your target audience, ultimately leading to improved results and ROI.

How Do You Conduct A/B Testing in Email Marketing?

Conducting an A/B testing in email marketing requires steps crucial for the whole process. Here are the steps you must take in conducting your testing: 

Define Your Objective

scrabble blocks letters
Your goals determine your path.

To start your A/B testing, set clear goals. Then, identify the specific metric you want to improve: open rates, click-through rates, conversions, or engagement. Doing so allows you to stay on track throughout the process. 

Select a Variable to Test

A/B testing allows you to discover the effectiveness of different variables. So, you can choose a single variable to test in your email, such as the subject line, sender name, email copy, call-to-action (CTA) button text or color, images, layout, or timing of sending.

Create Variations

Once you have clearly defined your objects and selected your preferred variables, you can develop two versions of your email, keeping everything else constant except for the variable you’re testing. For example, if you’re testing subject lines, create Version A with Subject Line A and Version B with Subject Line B.

Split Your Audience

After creating your email variations, randomly divide your email list into two equal segments: Group A and Group B. Make sure both groups represent your overall audience to get reliable results.

Send the Emails

Once you have identified your distinct group respondents, send Version A to Group A and Version B to Group B simultaneously or within a short time frame. Sending the emails simultaneously minimizes the impact of external factors that could skew the results.

Monitor Performance Metrics

Without monitoring your performance metrics, your testing holds no value. Hence, track the performance metrics related to your objective, such as open rates, click-through rates, conversions, or any other relevant KPIs. Use email marketing analytics tools to gather accurate data.

Collect Data

Don’t be in a hurry. Allow sufficient time for both versions of the email to generate results. Then, collect data on how each version performs based on your chosen metrics. 

Statistical Analysis

graphs and charts
Analytics show concrete data on your performance.

With your data, you can conduct statistical analysis to determine if the differences in performance between Version A and Version B are statistically significant. This step helps ensure that your findings are data-driven and not due to chance.

Draw Insights and Implement Them

Analyze the data to understand which version performed better and why. Consider factors such as audience preferences, messaging clarity, visual appeal, and relevance.

Furthermore, use the insights gained from the A/B test to optimize your future email campaigns. Apply the winning elements from the test (e.g., better-performing subject line, more effective CTA) to improve overall email engagement and ROI.

Repeat and Iterate

A/B testing in email marketing isn’t a one-time process. It is one that requires repetition. So, continuously test different variables and refine your strategies based on data-driven insights to continually improve the effectiveness of and upgrade your email marketing efforts.

What Are Examples of Email A/B Testing Tools?

people working on something
Marketing tools and software get the job done.

Several email marketing platforms offer built-in A/B testing tools that make it easy to conduct A/B tests directly within the platform. Here are some examples of popular email A/B testing tools:

Mailchimp

Mailchimp is an email marketing software that allows you to create A/B tests for various elements such as subject lines, sender names, content, and send times. You can define the test criteria, set the sample size and duration, and analyze the results within the Mailchimp dashboard. 

The tool offers a free plan for up to 2,000 contacts with limited features. Paid plans start at around $9.99 per month for up to 500 contacts, with A/B testing included in higher-tier plans.

Constant Contact

Constant Contact’s A/B testing in email marketing feature enables you to test different subject lines, email content, or sending times. You can customize the test settings and track performance metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversions.

Constant Contact’s pricing starts at around $20 a month for up to 500 contacts. A/B testing features are available in higher-tier plans, such as the Email Plus plan, which starts at around $45 per month.

We have a Constant Contact review you can check out for the details of the tool. 

Campaign Monitor

Campaign Monitor offers A/B testing in email marketing capabilities for testing subject lines, email content, and sender names. You can set up multiple variations, specify the test audience, and monitor the results in real-time. 

This tool’s pricing begins at around $9 per month for up to 500 contacts, with basic A/B testing features included. Advanced A/B testing capabilities are available in higher-tier plans, such as the Premier plan, which has custom pricing based on your needs.

HubSpot

HubSpot’s A/B testing in email marketing tool allows you to test different elements of your emails, such as subject lines, CTAs, images, and email templates. You can create multiple variations, define test criteria, and analyze performance metrics to optimize your email campaigns.

HubSpot offers a free email marketing tool with basic A/B testing features. Paid plans for more advanced features, including A/B testing, start at around $50 a month for the Starter plan.

You can visit our HubSpot review to learn more about this comprehensive tool. 

AWeber

AWeber’s A/B testing in email marketing feature lets you test subject lines, email content, sender information, and delivery times. You can split your audience into test groups, monitor engagement metrics, and make data-driven decisions to improve email performance.

The pricing of AWeber starts at around $19 per month for up to 500 subscribers, with basic A/B testing features included. More advanced A/B testing options are available in higher-tier plans, such as the Pro plan, which starts at around $49 per month.

GetResponse

GetResponse offers A/B testing in email marketing options for subject lines, email content, sender names, and delivery times. You can create variations, set test parameters, and track key metrics to determine the most effective elements for your audience. 

GetResponse’s pricing begins at around $15 monthly for up to 1,000 contacts, with basic A/B testing features included. Enhanced A/B testing capabilities are available in higher-tier plans, such as the Plus plan, which starts at around $49 a month.

These email marketing tools provide intuitive interfaces, detailed reporting, and automation features to streamline the A/B testing process and help you optimize your email marketing campaigns for better engagement and results. Best of all, most of these tools are for full-service marketing, offering more than just email marketing services like social media management, CRM, scheduling, and more. 

FAQs on A/B Testing in Email Marketing

A/B testing in email marketing is a broad process that involves many moving parts. Here, we answer some frequently asked questions you may have about the process.

What should be the sample size for an A/B test in email marketing?

The sample size for an A/B test in email marketing depends on factors such as your email list size, the significance level you want to achieve, and the expected effect size. Typically, larger sample sizes provide more statistically reliable results. Many email marketing platforms offer guidance or calculators to determine an appropriate sample size for your A/B tests.

How long should I run an A/B test for emails?

The duration of your A/B testing in email marketing depends on factors like your audience’s behavior, the frequency of emails sent, and the specific element being tested. It’s recommended to run tests for at least a few days to cover various time zones and behavioral patterns. Some tests, such as testing seasonal variations, may require longer durations to gather meaningful data.

What elements can I test in A/B testing for emails?

You can test various elements in A/B testing in email marketing, including subject lines, sender names, email content, CTAs, personalization, timing, frequency, segmentation, and mobile optimization. Testing these elements allows you to identify what drives better results and tailor your email campaigns accordingly.

Why is A/B testing important in email marketing?

A/B testing in email marketing is crucial in email marketing because it helps you understand what resonates best with your audience. By testing elements like subject lines, content, CTAs, and design, you can optimize your emails for higher engagement and conversion rates, improving campaign performance and ROI.

If you want to learn more about email marketing and how much it would cost you, head over to our “Email Marketing Costs: Factors to Consider for your Campaign Budget” article. 

Scroll to Top